Kidstir Review: Is This Cooking Subscription Box Good For Toddlers?

Feb 10, 2022Child Development, Cooking, Montessori, Product Reviews, Toddler Activities

This article may contain affiliate links, and we may earn a small commission when you click on a purchase link. There’s no extra cost to you, and we sincerely appreciate your support! You can read our full disclaimer policy here.

Kidstir Review: Is This Cooking Subscription Box Good For Toddlers?

Both of my toddlers stay at home currently, so I’m always looking for new activities to keep us busy. We’ve been testing lots of different toddler-focused subscription boxes, and I was extra excited about this cooking box from Kidstir!

My kids LOVE helping in the kitchen, even if it makes a recipe take twice as long (and the kitchen gets twice as dirty). We pulled up our kitchen helper and dug into our first Kidstir box. Here’s our experience using the Kidstir recipe cards with a 2 and 3.5-year-old.

And yes – I do have a special discount for you. Use code tmb10 for 10% off.

Kidstir Unboxing and First Impressions

kidstir cooking subscription for kids

The Kidstir box comes with:

  • Apron and chef’s hat
  • Kid-friendly utensil (ours was purple mini tongs)
  • 3 recipe cards (ours had a bonus card!)
kidstir unboxing

The box also comes with a little magazine, some achievement stickers, and a shopping list. But the apron, kid-friendly utensil, and recipe cards are the bulk of what you’re paying for.

kidstir items from unboxing

What I was most interested in were the recipe cards, and I was pretty happy with them! They looked relatively simple, and they were recipes I thought my kids would actually like. The one card I didn’t quite grasp until I looked closer was “Spaghetti & Beetballs.” I didn’t realize this was a vegan take on spaghetti and meatballs until we started preparing it… I’ll give my thoughts on that later in this article.

kidstir recipe cards

The apron and chef’s hat were really cute, but they were more of a novelty for my kids because they wouldn’t keep it on while cooking. They may be too young for it as well (3.5 and 2 years old).

Finally, the mini tongs we got are awesome, but our pair was a bit defective in that it won’t close up. The metal component on the bottom was bent a bit, so they stay perpetually opened. I reached out to customer service about it and they sent a replacement, free of charge.

Banana Oaty Muffins

kidstrong banana oaty muffins recipe card

For the banana oaty muffins recipe, my kids were able to help with a lot of the steps!

  • They loved peeling the bananas.
  • We use a kid-friendly masher to mash the bananas (though my 2-year-old kept trying to pick out pieces to eat).
  • Pouring the ingredients into the food processor was a lot of fun.
  • Both of my toddlers enjoyed taking turns pressing the “on” button on the food processor.
  • They helped sprinkle some oats on top of the muffins, though at this point, my 2-year-old’s main goal was to eat anything he could get his hands on (prepping food makes him hungry!).
  • My 3.5-year-old also enjoyed using a wooden crinkle cutter to make slices of banana for the tops of our muffins.
vera cutting banana

Yes, the final result turned out a little messy, but this was overall a success! The recipe is healthy, and I thought it was pretty delicious. 

Chocolate Snowball Macaroons

The kids were extra excited to make these snowballs drizzled in chocolate. What a fun way to name these coconut macaroons!

making macarons

They mainly helped with pouring and stirring, and of course, my son was trying to eat the concoction the entire time. 🙂

After my son went to bed, I had my daughter assist with the chocolate drizzle.

vera squeezing chocolate onto the snowball macarons

Yes, I’ll admit, I didn’t have it in me to handle the kind of mess my 2-year-old would create with melted chocolate. 

These were really fun to make, and they tasted yummy, too! I was surprised they turned out like the photos, to be honest!

vera very excited about her macarons

I also really like that this recipe is low-sugar and includes coconut. They really aren’t that sweet, but thanks to the chocolate drizzle, my kids ate them up!

vera enjoying the macarons

BFF Barkie Biscuits

This recipe card was actually listed as a bonus card, but I am SO glad it was in our box! We have a German Shepherd, Dash, and he absolutely LOVED these.

our dog loved these dog treats

And, this may have been my kid’s favorite recipe of all. They were stoked to make treats for Dash.

Plus, it almost felt like all the pressure was off to make these taste or look good. My 2-year-old just stuck his entire hand in the mixture after he just picked his nose? Who cares! It’s for the dog! 😂

jack stirring

The kids helped with every step, including cracking the eggs, because again – if some shell gets in there, who cares! Dash will love it.

cracking an egg

They mixed, poured, transferred, and rolled the dough ball. Playing with the dough was definitely my son’s favorite step.

jack kneading dough

I had to do most of the cut-outs, though I did let my kiddos take a turn. They just had trouble pressing hard enough for the cutter to go all the way through.

I didn’t have bone-shaped cutters, so we did star treats.

And these actually turned out really great! They were hard just like dog treats you’d buy, and our dog was obsessed with them. He would do anything for one of these treats – even go get in his crate. That’s really saying something.

finished dog treats

Spaghetti & Beetballs

Last but not least is the Spaghetti & Beetballs recipe. This one really threw me for a loop, because I didn’t realize it said “beetballs” for the longest time.

I have nothing against vegan versions of recipes, but I can’t say I was thrilled to make veggie meatballs out of beets and mushrooms. 

I did get the kid’s station all set up and had pretty high hopes.

But… I did not like this recipe for a multitude of reasons.

  1. I would’ve preferred regular meatballs, which are much faster and easier to prepare, and they are 100% easier to make with kids.
  2. WHY would you include beets in a recipe that kids will help with? I was frantic trying to clean up all the beet juice off our counters and floor. It was torture.
the massive mess that stressed me out
  1. The length of the recipe was a little long. From start to finish, it took about 2 hours.
  2. It didn’t taste horrible, but I also wouldn’t ever make it again. I could appreciate some of the flavors in this, but I’ll just be honest here. Regular beef meatballs would’ve been a lot tastier.
  3. The beetballs fell apart. You have to be really gentle with these or they’ll just crumble. 

After we finished the recipe and I got the massive mess cleaned up, I told my husband it was one of the worst experiences ever. But then I look back on the photos I took and saw how happy my kids were, and it gave me a little perspective.

I’m glad we did it. And I’m glad my kids had so much fun.

But I’m not sure I can handle another beetballs recipe. (Just being honest.)

Tips For Doing Kidstir With 2-3 Year-Olds

Cooking subscription boxes for kids are typically recommended for ages 5+. At this age, they’re much handier in the kitchen and can be involved in more of the steps.

Kidstir actually promotes their boxes for ages 4-14, but I have two toddlers, ages 2 and 3.5.

While our family isn’t 100% Montessori, we do follow many Montessori principles, one of which is involving our kids in real-life tasks, like cooking and cleaning (and making these things accessible to them). 

If you want your toddlers as young as 2 to help in the kitchen, you might be eyeing these subscription kits!

Here are some tips to consider before you go purchase the subscription:

  • You must be patient.

It is SO easy to get frustrated when you know you could finish a recipe in 10 minutes but it’s going to take 30 minutes when you involve your kids. Try to channel your inner zen and set aside extra time to involve the kids. I don’t recommend involving them if you have a time crunch. Make this a mid-day activity if you can!

kids stirring
  • Expect a mess.

Anytime you get a 2-year-old in the kitchen, there is going to be a mess. Again, expect it. Embrace it. Let it happen. And when you’re done, get the kids started on another independent activity so you can clean it all up.

mixing up beetball mixture
  • Prep some of the recipes in advance and save the easier tasks for your toddlers.

A 5, 6, or 7-year-old could probably help with most or all of the steps in this box. However, some of it was a little too advanced (or dangerous) for my toddlers.

Before we started a recipe together, I would read through it and do some of the steps myself before bringing in the kids.

As an example, for the macarons, I did the hand mixer part, but I did let my kids do the pouring and additional mixing.

me doing certain tasks in a recipe
  • Focus on mixing, pouring, cutting, and transferring.

Toddlers love to mix, pour, cut (with a kid-safe knife), and transfer. Any time this is needed in a recipe, bring in the kids! Even if it’s not conducive to completing the recipe, you can still make it part of the fun.

For example, set up two bowls and have your 2-year-old practice pouring your oats from one bowl to the other. They will love it!

So, is Kidstir appropriate for toddlers? I’d say yes! We really enjoyed it, and there are 3-4 recipe cards for the whole month, so you can space it out if the mess and patience required is a stressful experience for you.

Final Thoughts

Here’s the verdict: Kidstir is 100% worth it for families with toddlers as long as you can be patient and are OK with a messy kitchen.

It felt like a bit of work on my part, but toddlers learn SO much when you involve them in the kitchen. There are lots of STEM lessons happening, from counting to measuring to observing.

It’s fun and educational for your little ones, and hey, they may grow up to be one heck of a cook after helping you in the kitchen at such a young age.

Give Kidstir a try and let me know how it goes with your little ones. You can use code tmb10 for 10% off!

By Rebekah

By Rebekah

I'm a work-from-home mom with a supportive, hard-working husband, two toddlers, and a newborn. In the business world, I'm a copywriter with a deep background in marketing and SEO. At home, I'm always looking for mom hacks, the best projects and toys for my growing kiddos, and ways to solve everyday mom dilemmas. Whatever I find, I'm sharing on this blog, which is my passion project!

Join the Conversation!

5 2 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Suggested articles for you:

Get notified of new articles

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This