Today, I’m sharing my honest thoughts and experiences with both magnetic tile brands to help you make an informed choice. Let’s dive in!
Connetix vs. Magna-Tiles Comparison Chart
$1.02-$1.29 per tile
$1.20-$1.60 per tile
Now, let’s explore these points in more detail.
Durability: Metal Rivets Matter
Both brands use metal rivets to seal the tiles together, making them sturdy and less prone to breakage.
When it comes to durability, it’s a tie.
Magnetic Strength & Size: Connetix Comes Out on Top
When it comes to magnetic strength, weight matters.
I experimented and weighed the tiles, and Connetix emerged as the heavyweight champion at 33g per square.
In contrast, Magna-Tiles weighed in at 32g. A heavier tile translates to a stronger magnet, and that’s essential for creating stable structures.
Also, just visually, Connetix has thicker magnets, and you can feel the difference in stability and force when you connect two tiles together. The Magna-Tiles magnets are actually some of the thinnest in the bunch.
Connetix’s magnetic strength is unmatched, and I can vouch for it.
Expansion Packs: The Creative Edge
Magna-Tiles impresses with a wide variety of sets, including farm animals, dinosaurs, vehicles, and more.
They even introduced an exciting “in-motion collection” that adds a whole new dimension to play.
On the other hand, Connetix brings its A-game with gorgeous pastel sets, geometry sets, a remarkable ball run kit, and more.
What sets the Connetix ball run set apart is the clear tubing, allowing you to see the balls as they race through the tracks.
I found a huge set from Sam’s Club at an incredible price – just $0.71 per piece. You get a lot more pieces for less money than anywhere else, so I had to mention that!
Magna-Tiles has a huge collection that’s focused heavily on animals and dinosaurs. If that’s what your child is into, it might be worth sticking with Magna-Tiles.
However, Connetix really stole me heart with the ball run set, and the other expansion sets they have are functional, educational, and aesthetically gorgeous.
I have to say this one is looking like a tie.
Price: Connetix vs. Magna-Tiles
Technically, Magna-Tiles are slightly pricier, but the difference is negligible.
While Connetix comes out slightly cheaper, the price difference between these isn’t exactly a dealbreaker.
If you’re looking for a more budget-friendly option without compromising much on quality, I’d suggest checking out Picasso Tiles.
Aesthetics: Connetix’s Colorful Pop
One look at Connetix magnetic tiles, and you’ll be smitten by the vibrant colors and their unique beveled design. These tiles stand out from the pack.
On the other hand, Magna-Tiles – particularly their flagship 100-piece Classic set – is not so vibrant.
The choice here depends on your personal preference, but I can’t deny that Connetix’s aesthetics have won my heart.
Connetix vs. Magna-Tiles – Which One Is Better?
In my opinion, Connetix has taken the lead in this magnetic tile showdown.
Its combination of exceptional durability, magnetic strength, aesthetics, and unique expansion packs makes it a fantastic choice for our little ones.
I wish they were a tad more budget-friendly, but they’re slightly cheaper than Magna-Tiles.
That said, Magna-Tiles is far from being a losing choice.
They are the original magnetic tiles and have a special place in my heart.
Their wide range of expansion packs, durability, and competitive pricing make them a fantastic option, too.
Ultimately, which magnetic tile brand you choose depends on your preferences and priorities.
Whichever brand you choose, your kids will have a blast building, creating, and learning with these versatile magnetic tiles.